Unofficial File parts/s/60751s01.dat
part image
File Header:
0 ~Minifig Helmet with Cheek Protection and Thin Bands - Half
0 Name: s\60751s01.dat
0 Author: Evert-Jan Boer [ejboer]
0 !LDRAW_ORG Unofficial_Subpart
0 !LICENSE Redistributable under CCAL version 2.0 : see CAreadme.txt

0 BFC CERTIFY CCW

Status:
Needs more votes. (CN)
Size: 71913 bytes
Reviewers' certifications:
Holly-Wood=novote
MagFors=certify
Required (unofficial) subfiles:
(none)
Related (unofficial) subfiles:
Minifig Helmet with Cheek Protection and Thin Bands
Status: 1 subfile isn't certified. (CCSN)
Download: parts/60751.dat
File reviews and updates:
At Wed Oct 21 18:55:02 2020, the file was initially submitted.
Submitted by: ejboer
At Sat Nov 21 21:15:01 2020, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MagFors
Certification: hold
Comments:
I'm sorry but there are many things wrong here.

Missing edgelines:
2 4 -8.991 23.75 -12.975 -13.092 21.83 -12.135
2 4 -8.609 22.241 -13.041 -8.923 22.249 -13.459
2 4 -14.473 -2.75 2.5 -14.385 -2.75 3.375
2 4 -8.699 22.596 -13.026 -13.708 20.424 -11.5
2 4 -16.125 17.941 -9.465 -17.142 13.932 -8.027
2 4 -13.708 20.424 -11.5 -16.125 17.941 -9.465
2 4 -10.042 9.721 12.545 -9.181 1 10.982
2 4 -17.142 13.932 -8.027 -16.944 11.118 -7.595
2 4 -14.385 -2.75 -3.375 -14.473 -2.75 -2.5

Should be a condline:
2 14 -8.699 22.596 -13.026 -13.092 21.83 -12.135

These concave surfaces should be convex:
3 5 -9.566 .122 -12.845 -8.969 -2.75 -12.49 -9.635 -3.461 -12.58
3 5 -9.635 -3.461 -12.58 -10.922 -.058 -13.341 -9.566 .122 -12.845
3 5 -11.2109 .031 -11.5069 -10.922 -.058 -13.341 -9.635 -3.461 -12.58
3 5 -9.635 -3.461 -12.58 -10.385 -2.75 -11.056 -11.2109 .031 -11.5069
3 5 -10.191 23.75 -12.66 -10.798 23.194 -12.345 -15.004 20.782 -7.537
3 5 -15.004 20.782 -7.537 -14.073 23.75 -8.12 -10.191 23.75 -12.66
3 5 0 -.718 -16.56 -1.383 -4.923 -14.518 -3.003 -3.564 -14.921
3 5 -3.003 -3.564 -14.921 -3.003 -.988 -16.291 0 -.718 -16.56
3 5 -14.204 1 -6.773 -15.773 5.878 -6.028 -12.698 2.062 -9.918
3 5 -15.773 5.878 -6.028 -14.766 5.755 -8.147 -12.698 2.062 -9.918
3 5 -17.985 8.49 -3.903 -19.115 8.154 2.263 -18.851 8.523 -4
3 5 -17.985 8.49 -3.903 -18.266 8.136 0 -19.115 8.154 2.263
3 5 -19.251 16.795 7.981 -17.402 8.762 5.994 -14.448 9.374 9.881
3 5 -15.698 16.944 12.816 -19.251 16.795 7.981 -14.448 9.374 9.881
3 5 -4.418 5.965 -14.8 -9.77 3.197 -12.797 -9.1923 4.568 -9.1923
3 5 -4.9751 6.8256 -12.0107 -4.418 5.965 -14.8 -9.1923 4.568 -9.1923

This convex surface should be concave:
3 13 -14.766 5.755 -8.147 -10.9102 7.894 -6.6218 -9.1923 4.568 -9.1923
3 13 -12.698 2.062 -9.918 -14.766 5.755 -8.147 -9.1923 4.568 -9.1923

This needs to be changes so that tyhe surface is convex when mirrored:
3 11 0 -.718 -16.56 -1.738 3.348 -16.947 0 5.419 -16.596
3 11 0 -6.081 -13.52 -1.383 -4.923 -14.518 0 -.718 -16.56

I'm not sure, but I think these should be edgelines:
2 10 -3.338 -11.331 -2.886 -3.311 -10.517 -2.921
2 10 -3.135 -11.403 3.088 -3.135 -10.521 3.088
2 10 -3.135 -10.521 -3.088 -3.135 -11.403 -3.088
2 10 -3.311 -10.517 2.921 -3.338 -11.331 2.886
At Mon Jan 25 20:00:01 2021, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: ejboer
Comments:
Lots of changes as proposed, redid the front notch(?) to get a better surface

Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Sun Feb 14 17:20:02 2021, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MagFors
Certification: certify
No comments were posted with this review.

At Tue Mar 2 14:35:01 2021, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Holly-Wood
Certification: novote
Comments:
I'm not gonna vote on this part as I think that this:

3 16 -12.603 -2.75 -8.811 -14.291 1 -8.009 -11.2109 .031 -11.5069
3 16 -11.2109 .031 -11.5069 -14.291 1 -8.009 -11.383 1 -11.781
3 16 -16.708 2.609 -2.5 -17.289 5.062 -3.746 -15.989 1 -3.555
3 16 -16.708 2.609 -2.5 -15.989 1 -3.555 -15.582 -1.322 -2.5
3 16 -15.582 -1.322 -2.5 -15.989 1 -3.555 -15.173 -2.75 -2.5
3 16 -17.246 4.874 3.737 -16.708 2.609 2.5 -15.992 1 3.555
3 16 -15.992 1 3.555 -16.708 2.609 2.5 -15.582 -1.322 2.5
3 16 -15.992 1 3.555 -15.582 -1.322 2.5 -15.173 -2.75 2.5
5 24 -15.173 -2.75 2.5 -15.992 1 3.555 -15.304 1 5.845 -15.582 -1.322 2.5
5 24 -16.708 2.609 2.5 -15.992 1 3.555 -15.582 -1.322 2.5 -17.246 4.874 3.737
5 24 -17.246 4.874 3.737 -16.708 2.609 2.5 -15.992 1 3.555 -17.555 4.707 0
5 24 -11.2109 .031 -11.5069 -12.603 -2.75 -8.811 -14.291 1 -8.009 -10.385 -2.75 -11.056
5 24 -14.291 1 -8.009 -11.2109 .031 -11.5069 -12.603 -2.75 -8.811 -11.383 1 -11.781
5 24 -11.383 1 -11.781 -11.2109 .031 -11.5069 -14.291 1 -8.009 -10.9702 .5529 -11.9552
5 24 -16.708 2.609 -2.5 -15.989 1 -3.555 -15.582 -1.322 -2.5 -17.289 5.062 -3.746
5 24 -16.708 2.609 -2.5 -17.289 5.062 -3.746 -17.555 4.707 0 -15.989 1 -3.555
5 24 -15.989 1 -3.555 -15.173 -2.75 -2.5 -15.582 -1.322 -2.5 -12.603 -2.75 -8.811

would be a much better code in some areas (less edgy in LDView)