Unofficial File parts/33086.dat
part image
File Header:
0 Scala Arch 22 x 2 x 16 1/3
0 Name: 33086.dat
0 Author: Tore Eriksson [Tore_Eriksson]
0 !LDRAW_ORG Unofficial_Part
0 !LICENSE Redistributable under CCAL version 2.0 : see CAreadme.txt

0 BFC CERTIFY CCW
Status:
2 'hold' votes. (HHN)
Size: 46515 bytes
Reviewers' certifications:
MMR1988=novote
MagFors=hold
Steffen=hold
Required (unofficial) subfiles:
(none)
Related (unofficial) subfiles:
(none)
File reviews and updates:
At Tue Aug 29 16:50:01 2017, the file was initially submitted.
Submitted by: Tore_Eriksson
Comments:
Could be really cool in a Cathedral or a Modular-ish Gothic MOC building.

At Tue Aug 29 16:55:00 2017, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Tore_Eriksson
Certification: hold
Comments:
Several BFC problems.

At Tue Aug 29 18:05:01 2017, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: Tore_Eriksson
Comments:
Problems fixed, (hopefully...)

Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Thu Aug 31 22:20:00 2017, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MagFors
Certification: novote
Comments:
Interesting piece, and an impressive work. A real labour of love.

But, still many issues:
Line 82: Identical to line 78: 1 16 212 96 -15 0 1 0 76 0 0 0 0 1 rect.dat
Line 83: Identical to line 79: 1 16 -212 96 -15 0 -1 0 76 0 0 0 0 1 rect.dat
Line 256: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 4.65595577554821): 4 16 188 179 20 216 179 20 216 179 -16 188 180 0
Line 257: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 4.65595577554821): 4 16 -188 179 20 -188 180 0 -216 179 -16 -216 179 20
Line 258: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 4.65595577554821): 4 16 188 189 20 188 188 0 216 189 -16 216 189 20
Line 259: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 4.65595577554821): 4 16 -188 189 20 -216 189 20 -216 189 -16 -188 188 0
Line 260: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 3.99872297592737): 4 16 216 179 -16 184 180 -16 184 180 0 188 180 0
Line 261: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 3.99872297592737): 4 16 -216 179 -16 -188 180 0 -184 180 0 -184 180 -16
Line 262: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 3.99872297592737): 4 16 216 189 -16 188 188 0 184 188 0 184 188 -16
Line 263: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 3.99872297592737): 4 16 -216 189 -16 -184 188 -16 -184 188 0 -188 188 0
Line 312: Identical to line 124: 2 24 183 179.5 20 183 180 20
Line 313: Identical to line 125: 2 24 -183 179.5 20 -183 180 20
Line 372: Identical to line 348: 2 24 180 392 -20 220 392 -20
Line 373: Identical to line 349: 2 24 -180 392 -20 -220 392 -20
Line 533: Identical to line 531: 4 16 50.22 61 -12 57.4 64.66 -12 64 53.5 -12 56 49.1 -12
Line 534: Identical to line 532: 4 16 -50.22 61 -12 -56 49.1 -12 -64 53.5 -12 -57.4 64.66 -12
Line 573: Identical to line 571: 4 16 64.57 69.27 -12 71.75 74.7 -12 80 64.7 -12 72 58.6 -12
Line 574: Identical to line 572: 4 16 -64.57 69.27 -12 -72 58.6 -12 -80 64.7 -12 -71.75 74.7 -12
Line 613: Identical to line 611: 4 16 78.92 81.13 -12 86.1 88.81 -12 96 80.4 -12 88 71.8 -12
Line 614: Identical to line 612: 4 16 -78.92 81.13 -12 -88 71.8 -12 -96 80.4 -12 -86.1 88.81 -12
Line 653: Identical to line 651: 4 16 93.27 98.21 -12 100.44 110.23 -12 112 104.3 -12 104 90.9 -12
Line 654: Identical to line 652: 4 16 -93.27 98.21 -12 -104 90.9 -12 -112 104.3 -12 -100.44 110.23 -12
Line 717: Identical to line 715: 4 16 117.52 119.68 -12 124.53 121.33 -12 128 108.86 -12 120 106.92 -12
Line 718: Identical to line 716: 4 16 -117.52 119.68 -12 -120 106.92 -12 -128 108.86 -12 -124.53 121.33 -12
Line 757: Identical to line 755: 4 16 131.54 123.58 -12 138.55 126.47 -12 144 114.66 -12 136 111.36 -12
Line 758: Identical to line 756: 4 16 -131.54 123.58 -12 -136 111.36 -12 -144 114.66 -12 -138.55 126.47 -12
Line 797: Identical to line 795: 4 16 145.56 130.07 -12 152.57 134.5 -12 160 123.83 -12 152 118.78 -12
Line 798: Identical to line 796: 4 16 -145.56 130.07 -12 -152 118.78 -12 -160 123.83 -12 -152.57 134.5 -12
Line 837: Identical to line 835: 4 16 159.58 139.9 -12 166.59 146.52 -12 176 137.55 -12 168 129.99 -12
Line 838: Identical to line 836: 4 16 -159.58 139.9 -12 -168 129.99 -12 -176 137.55 -12 -166.59 146.52 -12

Missing edges, front and backside of all the vertical bars:
2 4 176 36 -8 -176 36 -8
2 4 176 36 -12 -176 36 -12

Missing and misplaced edges, and cond-lines, both left and right leg:
in the 'knee'
2 4 -216 376 -16 -184 376 -16
2 4 -183 188.5 20 -188 188.5 20
2 4 -188 188.5 20 -188 189 20
2 12 -188 189 20 -183 188.5 20
on the arch:
5 14 -31.02 39.88 -12 -31.02 39.88 -8 -40 42.5 -12 -22 38 -12
5 14 -100.44 110.23 -12 -100.44 110.23 -8 -101.44 114.48 -8 -93.27 98.21 -8
5 14 -166.59 146.52 -12 -166.59 146.52 -8 -159.58 139.9 -8 -173.6 154.8 -8
5 14 -173.6 154.8 -12 -173.6 154.8 -8 -166.59 146.52 -8 -180 164.56 -8

Hidden, unnecessary surfaces inside the feet, bleeding through surface above, both left and right leg.
4 13 -216 376 -16 -184 376 -16 -196 380 -16 -204 380 -16
4 13 -184 376 -16 -184 392 -16 -196 388 -16 -196 380 -16
4 13 -216 392 -16 -216 376 -16 -204 380 -16 -204 388 -16
4 13 -216 376 16 -204 380 16 -196 380 16 -184 376 16
4 13 -184 376 16 -196 380 16 -196 388 16 -184 392 16
4 13 -216 392 16 -204 388 16 -204 380 16 -216 376 16

Gaps in the pin-hole, in the 'knee', both left and right leg:
2 4 -201.531 187.695 20 -202.211 187.333 20
2 4 -202.211 187.333 20 -202.8284 186.8284 20
2 4 -198.4692 187.6956 20 -197.789 187.333 20
2 4 -197.789 187.333 20 -197.172 186.828 20
2 4 -201.531 180.305 20 -202.211 180.667 20
2 4 -202.211 180.667 20 -202.8284 181.1716 20
2 4 -198.4692 180.3044 20 -197.789 180.667 20
2 4 -197.789 180.667 20 -197.172 181.172 20

At Tue Jan 9 00:45:00 2018, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Steffen
Certification: hold
Comments:
nice part!
identical lines confirmed

At Sat Jun 1 09:10:01 2019, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: Cheenzo
Comments:
Tried to fix everything. Let me know if I forgot anything

Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Sat Jun 1 13:55:02 2019, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Steffen
Certification: hold
Comments:
8 BFC errors inside underside of bottom 2x2 "bricks"

At Sun Jun 2 21:40:01 2019, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: Cheenzo
Comments:
Fixed BFC errors

Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Sun Jun 2 21:55:01 2019, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Steffen
Certification: hold
Comments:
- long horizontal edge missing in rear top cavity
- 1 edge missing on each side when viewing bottom 2x2 brick from below
- horizontal edges missing on middle 2x2 bricks
- part should generally be double checked against more missing edges

At Mon Jun 3 08:25:01 2019, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Philo
Certification: novote
Comments:
In addition to Steffen suggestions, there are several missing condlines:
5 24 -188 180 0 -184 180 0 -188 179.5 20 -216 179 -16
5 24 -166.59 146.52 -12 -166.59 146.52 -8 -173.6 154.8 -12 -159.58 139.9 -8
5 24 188 188 0 184 188 0 216 189 -16 188 188.5 20
5 24 216 179 -16 188 180 0 188 179 20 184 180 0
5 24 -216 189 -16 -188 188 0 -184 188 0 -188 189 20
5 24 -31.02 39.88 -8 -31.02 39.88 -12 -40 42.5 -8 -22 38 -12
5 24 -184 188 0 -188 188 0 -183 188.5 20 -216 189 -16
5 24 100.44 110.23 -8 100.44 110.23 -12 93.27 98.21 -12 101.44 114.48 -8
5 24 166.59 146.52 -8 166.59 146.52 -12 173.6 154.8 -8 159.58 139.9 -12
5 24 188 188 0 216 189 -16 184 188 0 188 189 20
5 24 31.02 39.88 -12 31.02 39.88 -8 40 42.5 -12 22 38 -8
5 24 -173.6 154.8 -12 -173.6 154.8 -8 -166.59 146.52 -8 -180 164.56 -12
5 24 -100.44 110.23 -12 -100.44 110.23 -8 -93.27 98.21 -8 -101.44 114.48 -12
5 24 184 180 0 188 180 0 183 179.5 20 216 179 -16
5 24 -188 180 0 -216 179 -16 -188 179 20 -184 180 0
5 24 173.6 154.8 -8 173.6 154.8 -12 180 164.56 -8 166.59 146.52 -12

And this line
2 4 188 189 20 183 188.5 20
is misplaced (two lines missing nearby)

At Mon Jun 3 16:40:01 2019, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: Cheenzo
Comments:
Thanks! I checked for further missing edge but did not find any. Added condlines too.

Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Mon Jun 3 18:05:01 2019, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MMR1988
Certification: novote
Comments:
Misses some condlines around the outer faces of the little holes.
The edges, where these outer surfaces meet the bottom/top next to it are missing, too.

At Mon Jun 3 23:55:01 2019, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Steffen
Certification: hold
Comments:
still at least 1 edge missing
a horizontal edge where the right column meets the bottom 2x3 foot.

At Tue Jun 4 00:25:01 2019, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Steffen
Certification: hold
Comments:
sorry, typo, meant 2x2 of course

At Sun Jun 9 16:55:01 2019, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MagFors
Certification: hold
Comments:

I think Steffen meen this line is missing:
2 4 184 376 -16 216 376 -16


And I think Max is talking about this area:
3 13 188 189 20 188 188 0 216 189 -16
3 13 216 189 -16 216 189 20 188 189 20
3 13 216 189 -16 188 188 0 184 188 0
3 13 184 188 0 184 188 -16 216 189 -16
4 12 203.317 189 20 204.243 188.243 20 204.243 188.243 -16 203.317 189 -16
4 12 195.757 188.243 20 196.683 189 20 196.683 189 -16 195.757 188.243 -16
These surfaces are intersecting and missing edges and condlines.
The same error is present on all four similar surfaces, inside that box in the middle of both legs.