Unofficial File parts/33086.dat
part image
File Header:
0 Scala Arch 22 x  2 x 16  1/3
0 Name: 33086.dat
0 Author: Tore Eriksson [Tore_Eriksson]
0 !LDRAW_ORG Unofficial_Part
0 !LICENSE Redistributable under CCAL version 2.0 : see CAreadme.txt

0 BFC CERTIFY CCW

0 !HISTORY 2020-05-13 [Holly-Wood] Added missing edge at bottom, rebuild partly center section

0 // Center Column right
Status:
Needs more votes. (CN)
Size: 49165 bytes
Reviewers' certifications:
MMR1988=certify
Required (unofficial) subfiles:
(none)
Related (unofficial) subfiles:
(none)
File reviews and updates:
At Tue Aug 29 16:50:01 2017, the file was initially submitted.
Submitted by: Tore_Eriksson
Comments:
Could be really cool in a Cathedral or a Modular-ish Gothic MOC building.

At Tue Aug 29 16:55:00 2017, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Tore_Eriksson
Certification: hold
Comments:
Several BFC problems.

At Tue Aug 29 18:05:01 2017, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: Tore_Eriksson
Comments:
Problems fixed, (hopefully...)

Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Thu Aug 31 22:20:00 2017, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MagFors
Certification: novote
Comments:
Interesting piece, and an impressive work. A real labour of love.

But, still many issues:
Line 82: Identical to line 78: 1 16 212 96 -15 0 1 0 76 0 0 0 0 1 rect.dat
Line 83: Identical to line 79: 1 16 -212 96 -15 0 -1 0 76 0 0 0 0 1 rect.dat
Line 256: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 4.65595577554821): 4 16 188 179 20 216 179 20 216 179 -16 188 180 0
Line 257: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 4.65595577554821): 4 16 -188 179 20 -188 180 0 -216 179 -16 -216 179 20
Line 258: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 4.65595577554821): 4 16 188 189 20 188 188 0 216 189 -16 216 189 20
Line 259: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 4.65595577554821): 4 16 -188 189 20 -216 189 20 -216 189 -16 -188 188 0
Line 260: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 3.99872297592737): 4 16 216 179 -16 184 180 -16 184 180 0 188 180 0
Line 261: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 3.99872297592737): 4 16 -216 179 -16 -188 180 0 -184 180 0 -184 180 -16
Line 262: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 3.99872297592737): 4 16 216 189 -16 188 188 0 184 188 0 184 188 -16
Line 263: Quad points not coplaner (angle = 3.99872297592737): 4 16 -216 189 -16 -184 188 -16 -184 188 0 -188 188 0
Line 312: Identical to line 124: 2 24 183 179.5 20 183 180 20
Line 313: Identical to line 125: 2 24 -183 179.5 20 -183 180 20
Line 372: Identical to line 348: 2 24 180 392 -20 220 392 -20
Line 373: Identical to line 349: 2 24 -180 392 -20 -220 392 -20
Line 533: Identical to line 531: 4 16 50.22 61 -12 57.4 64.66 -12 64 53.5 -12 56 49.1 -12
Line 534: Identical to line 532: 4 16 -50.22 61 -12 -56 49.1 -12 -64 53.5 -12 -57.4 64.66 -12
Line 573: Identical to line 571: 4 16 64.57 69.27 -12 71.75 74.7 -12 80 64.7 -12 72 58.6 -12
Line 574: Identical to line 572: 4 16 -64.57 69.27 -12 -72 58.6 -12 -80 64.7 -12 -71.75 74.7 -12
Line 613: Identical to line 611: 4 16 78.92 81.13 -12 86.1 88.81 -12 96 80.4 -12 88 71.8 -12
Line 614: Identical to line 612: 4 16 -78.92 81.13 -12 -88 71.8 -12 -96 80.4 -12 -86.1 88.81 -12
Line 653: Identical to line 651: 4 16 93.27 98.21 -12 100.44 110.23 -12 112 104.3 -12 104 90.9 -12
Line 654: Identical to line 652: 4 16 -93.27 98.21 -12 -104 90.9 -12 -112 104.3 -12 -100.44 110.23 -12
Line 717: Identical to line 715: 4 16 117.52 119.68 -12 124.53 121.33 -12 128 108.86 -12 120 106.92 -12
Line 718: Identical to line 716: 4 16 -117.52 119.68 -12 -120 106.92 -12 -128 108.86 -12 -124.53 121.33 -12
Line 757: Identical to line 755: 4 16 131.54 123.58 -12 138.55 126.47 -12 144 114.66 -12 136 111.36 -12
Line 758: Identical to line 756: 4 16 -131.54 123.58 -12 -136 111.36 -12 -144 114.66 -12 -138.55 126.47 -12
Line 797: Identical to line 795: 4 16 145.56 130.07 -12 152.57 134.5 -12 160 123.83 -12 152 118.78 -12
Line 798: Identical to line 796: 4 16 -145.56 130.07 -12 -152 118.78 -12 -160 123.83 -12 -152.57 134.5 -12
Line 837: Identical to line 835: 4 16 159.58 139.9 -12 166.59 146.52 -12 176 137.55 -12 168 129.99 -12
Line 838: Identical to line 836: 4 16 -159.58 139.9 -12 -168 129.99 -12 -176 137.55 -12 -166.59 146.52 -12

Missing edges, front and backside of all the vertical bars:
2 4 176 36 -8 -176 36 -8
2 4 176 36 -12 -176 36 -12

Missing and misplaced edges, and cond-lines, both left and right leg:
in the 'knee'
2 4 -216 376 -16 -184 376 -16
2 4 -183 188.5 20 -188 188.5 20
2 4 -188 188.5 20 -188 189 20
2 12 -188 189 20 -183 188.5 20
on the arch:
5 14 -31.02 39.88 -12 -31.02 39.88 -8 -40 42.5 -12 -22 38 -12
5 14 -100.44 110.23 -12 -100.44 110.23 -8 -101.44 114.48 -8 -93.27 98.21 -8
5 14 -166.59 146.52 -12 -166.59 146.52 -8 -159.58 139.9 -8 -173.6 154.8 -8
5 14 -173.6 154.8 -12 -173.6 154.8 -8 -166.59 146.52 -8 -180 164.56 -8

Hidden, unnecessary surfaces inside the feet, bleeding through surface above, both left and right leg.
4 13 -216 376 -16 -184 376 -16 -196 380 -16 -204 380 -16
4 13 -184 376 -16 -184 392 -16 -196 388 -16 -196 380 -16
4 13 -216 392 -16 -216 376 -16 -204 380 -16 -204 388 -16
4 13 -216 376 16 -204 380 16 -196 380 16 -184 376 16
4 13 -184 376 16 -196 380 16 -196 388 16 -184 392 16
4 13 -216 392 16 -204 388 16 -204 380 16 -216 376 16

Gaps in the pin-hole, in the 'knee', both left and right leg:
2 4 -201.531 187.695 20 -202.211 187.333 20
2 4 -202.211 187.333 20 -202.8284 186.8284 20
2 4 -198.4692 187.6956 20 -197.789 187.333 20
2 4 -197.789 187.333 20 -197.172 186.828 20
2 4 -201.531 180.305 20 -202.211 180.667 20
2 4 -202.211 180.667 20 -202.8284 181.1716 20
2 4 -198.4692 180.3044 20 -197.789 180.667 20
2 4 -197.789 180.667 20 -197.172 181.172 20

At Tue Jan 9 00:45:00 2018, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Steffen
Certification: hold
Comments:
nice part!
identical lines confirmed

At Sat Jun 1 09:10:01 2019, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: Cheenzo
Comments:
Tried to fix everything. Let me know if I forgot anything

Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Sat Jun 1 13:55:02 2019, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Steffen
Certification: hold
Comments:
8 BFC errors inside underside of bottom 2x2 "bricks"

At Sun Jun 2 21:40:01 2019, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: Cheenzo
Comments:
Fixed BFC errors

Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Sun Jun 2 21:55:01 2019, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Steffen
Certification: hold
Comments:
- long horizontal edge missing in rear top cavity
- 1 edge missing on each side when viewing bottom 2x2 brick from below
- horizontal edges missing on middle 2x2 bricks
- part should generally be double checked against more missing edges

At Mon Jun 3 08:25:01 2019, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Philo
Certification: novote
Comments:
In addition to Steffen suggestions, there are several missing condlines:
5 24 -188 180 0 -184 180 0 -188 179.5 20 -216 179 -16
5 24 -166.59 146.52 -12 -166.59 146.52 -8 -173.6 154.8 -12 -159.58 139.9 -8
5 24 188 188 0 184 188 0 216 189 -16 188 188.5 20
5 24 216 179 -16 188 180 0 188 179 20 184 180 0
5 24 -216 189 -16 -188 188 0 -184 188 0 -188 189 20
5 24 -31.02 39.88 -8 -31.02 39.88 -12 -40 42.5 -8 -22 38 -12
5 24 -184 188 0 -188 188 0 -183 188.5 20 -216 189 -16
5 24 100.44 110.23 -8 100.44 110.23 -12 93.27 98.21 -12 101.44 114.48 -8
5 24 166.59 146.52 -8 166.59 146.52 -12 173.6 154.8 -8 159.58 139.9 -12
5 24 188 188 0 216 189 -16 184 188 0 188 189 20
5 24 31.02 39.88 -12 31.02 39.88 -8 40 42.5 -12 22 38 -8
5 24 -173.6 154.8 -12 -173.6 154.8 -8 -166.59 146.52 -8 -180 164.56 -12
5 24 -100.44 110.23 -12 -100.44 110.23 -8 -93.27 98.21 -8 -101.44 114.48 -12
5 24 184 180 0 188 180 0 183 179.5 20 216 179 -16
5 24 -188 180 0 -216 179 -16 -188 179 20 -184 180 0
5 24 173.6 154.8 -8 173.6 154.8 -12 180 164.56 -8 166.59 146.52 -12

And this line
2 4 188 189 20 183 188.5 20
is misplaced (two lines missing nearby)

At Mon Jun 3 16:40:01 2019, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: Cheenzo
Comments:
Thanks! I checked for further missing edge but did not find any. Added condlines too.

Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Mon Jun 3 18:05:01 2019, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MMR1988
Certification: novote
Comments:
Misses some condlines around the outer faces of the little holes.
The edges, where these outer surfaces meet the bottom/top next to it are missing, too.

At Mon Jun 3 23:55:01 2019, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Steffen
Certification: hold
Comments:
still at least 1 edge missing
a horizontal edge where the right column meets the bottom 2x3 foot.

At Tue Jun 4 00:25:01 2019, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Steffen
Certification: hold
Comments:
sorry, typo, meant 2x2 of course

At Sun Jun 9 16:55:01 2019, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MagFors
Certification: hold
Comments:

I think Steffen meen this line is missing:
2 4 184 376 -16 216 376 -16


And I think Max is talking about this area:
3 13 188 189 20 188 188 0 216 189 -16
3 13 216 189 -16 216 189 20 188 189 20
3 13 216 189 -16 188 188 0 184 188 0
3 13 184 188 0 184 188 -16 216 189 -16
4 12 203.317 189 20 204.243 188.243 20 204.243 188.243 -16 203.317 189 -16
4 12 195.757 188.243 20 196.683 189 20 196.683 189 -16 195.757 188.243 -16
These surfaces are intersecting and missing edges and condlines.
The same error is present on all four similar surfaces, inside that box in the middle of both legs.
At Wed May 13 11:30:02 2020, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: Holly-Wood
Comments:
Added missing edge at bottom, rebuild partly center section

Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Mon May 18 09:15:02 2020, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MagFors
Certification: hold
Comments:
Much better now.
Still missing four sets of condlines, like these:
5 4 -195.7574 179.7574 -16 -195.7574 179.7574 20 -194.45661884 181.70390488 20 -196.683 179 20
5 4 -195.7574 188.2426 -16 -195.7574 188.2426 20 -194.45661884 186.29609512 20 -196.89 189 20

At Mon May 18 11:20:02 2020, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: Holly-Wood
Comments:
Added conds. Fixed BFC error

Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Wed May 20 17:15:01 2020, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MagFors
Certification: certify
No comments were posted with this review.

At Wed May 20 22:55:02 2020, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MMR1988
Certification: hold
Comments:
This edge is missing:
2 24 -216 176 -16 -184 176 -16#
otherwise the part is fine.

At Thu May 21 08:15:01 2020, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: Holly-Wood
Comments:
Added edge

Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Fri May 22 20:40:01 2020, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MMR1988
Certification: certify
No comments were posted with this review.