Unofficial File parts/24077.dat
part image
File Header:
0 Minifig Crutch
0 Name: 24077.dat
0 Author: Ulrich Röder [UR]
0 !LDRAW_ORG Unofficial_Part
0 !LICENSE Redistributable under CCAL version 2.0 : see CAreadme.txt

0 BFC CERTIFY CCW

0 !CATEGORY Minifig Accessory

Status:
1 subfile isn't certified. (CCSN)
Size: 52014 bytes
Reviewers' certifications:
MagFors=certify
Philo=certify
Required (unofficial) subfiles:
Torus Outside 1 x 0.4000 x 0.5
Status: Needs more votes. (N)
Download: p/t02o4000.dat
Related (unofficial) subfiles:
(none)
File reviews and updates:
At Fri Aug 24 18:50:01 2018, the file was initially submitted.
Submitted by: UR
At Fri Aug 24 19:15:01 2018, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: SLS
Certification: novote
Comments:
Top of the fork's branches are missing.

At Fri Aug 24 19:20:01 2018, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: arezey
Certification: hold
Comments:
Hi, welcome to the Parts Tracker!

some problems I found in this submission:
* file is invalid UTF-8. It is currently in ISO-8859. Your name is showing up incorrectly.
* torus primitive is not uploaded
* missing edges where the cylinder rib is meeting the interior sweep
* what's the point of the two subparts? Is this part patterned?
* "No 1" should be removed from the description
* The circular recesses could be replaced with discs and cones. They seem unnecessarily high-resolution for such small details. 16 segments would work fine.

At Sat Aug 25 18:20:02 2018 a Parts Tracker Admin edited the header.
At Sat Aug 25 18:20:02 2018 a Parts Tracker Admin edited the header.
At Sat Aug 25 18:25:01 2018, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: UR
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Sat Aug 25 19:30:01 2018, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: UR
Certification: novote
Comments:
Thank you for your welcome, arezey!
Everything revised after your criticisms.
Subfiles can be deleted.

At Sat Sep 8 20:15:01 2018, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: UR
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Sun Sep 9 10:40:01 2018, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Steffen
Certification: hold
Comments:
still some required files missing - did you forget to upload them?

At Sun Sep 9 12:10:01 2018, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Philo
Certification: novote
Comments:
...and "4-4ring26w14.dat" doesn't fit regular primitive nomenclature. What is it supposed to be?

At Sun Sep 9 12:30:02 2018, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MagFors
Certification: hold
Comments:
The use of a non standard ring primtive make it, afaik, impossible to certify this.
A simple disc would work better.

The same goes for the top of the handle.
Many thin 2-4ring prims is not wanted. A 2-4disc, or even better a 2-4chrd, would be enough.

This design suffers from the same problem as your very detailed stickers. To many vertices. It needs to be simplified.
At Sun Sep 9 23:50:01 2018, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: UR
Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Mon Sep 10 05:50:01 2018, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Philo
Certification: hold
Comments:
Overall, looks good! but...
- Missing edge lines where the lower bar meets sides.
- Wrong condlines overlapping edge lines on sides of the crutch. This causes weird shading.
- the lower bar should be made from 4-4cyli+4-4cyls+4-4edge primitives

At Mon Sep 10 16:50:02 2018, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: UR
Comments:
Thank you Phillipe....done so far

In LDview... it looks like 2 shading irritations.. each inside above the lower bar...searched like a Bajazzo for a Solution...but i have no idea.....everthing seems to be fine.

Or is this acceptable ...or not significant?

Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Mon Sep 10 18:10:02 2018, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Philo
Certification: certify
Comments:
Now I feel bad! These condines come from the cyli primitives, so there is nothing to do to improve...

At Mon Sep 10 20:00:01 2018, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MagFors
Certification: novote
Comments:
Looks good, but the edges at the big end should be made using prims.

The handle could be made only one cylse
1 1 6.6 -34 0 0 -9.4 1.9 0 0 -4 4 0 0 4-4cyli.dat
1 1 6.6 -34 0 0 -1 1.9 0 0 -4 4 0 0 4-4edge.dat
1 1 -2.8 -34 0 -1.9 -3.8 0 4 0 0 0 0 4 4-4cylse.dat
At Mon Sep 10 21:45:01 2018, a new version of the file was submitted.
Submitted by: UR
Comments:
Do not feel bad....Phillipe..everything is fine..that brought me finally exact to this thought you have analyzed....it was a good help for getting deeper into the LDraw stuff.

Would it be an idea.. to change cyli against cyli2 in those sections?

....and thank you for certifying

fine idea Magnus..ingenious !!

I allowed myself to do it that way....thank you.

Existing certification-votes were deleted.
At Tue Sep 11 16:20:01 2018, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: MagFors
Certification: certify
Comments:
Your welcome.
At Tue Sep 11 17:45:01 2018, the following review was posted:

Reviewer: Philo
Certification: certify
No comments were posted with this review.

At Sat Dec 8 15:50:02 2018 a Parts Tracker Admin edited the header.