Voting Results - L-Cad dat vote 9902 10 vote-sheets tallied - some were partial/incomplete -READ THIS!!!!!! Included in this update is the new makelist program, MKLIST.exe. This program appears to work on all DOS/Win9x/WinNT platforms. Please use this program instead of makelst2 or makelst3. If you have any problems, please let us know! Also included is the source code in the file mklist-C.zip. Users of LDAO can still use that programs internal makelist utility as well. -Below is the raw data for the vote. Be advised that not all pieces listed below are included in this update! 1. Some pieces did not pass. 2. Some pieces that nominally "passed" generated quite a few questions as to their accuracy. Upon close examination, I concurred that those parts did indeed have serious problems. As a result of those questions, and my examination, those pieces have been removed. Furthur info below. 3. There is an ongoing effort to widen the scope of represented parts within LDraw. Some of the pieces in the current voting need to be held briefly in order to minimize the need for later renamings and/or renumberings. The held pieces are noted below. Better to have some released now, right? -Pieces marked with an * by the number had some sort of modification to name and/or description. Details below. All parts starting with an X that did not get new correct numbers had the X dropped. Yes No Abstain Name Description -- -- -- ------- -------------------------------- 7 0 2 2443 Hinge Window Frame 1 x 4 x 3 with Octagonal Panel 6 0 3 *2524 Minifig Backpack 4 4 1 2552 Baseplate 32 x 32 Raised with Ramp (needs work) 5 0 4 *2574 [category?] Pull-Back Motor 8 0 1 2621 Boat Bow Plate 10 x 9 7 0 2 2919 Electric Train Light Prism 1 x 4 4 3 2 3004P01 Brick 1 x 2 with Computer Screen and Buttons Pattern 8 0 1 *30086 Boat 8 x 12 Inflatable Dinghy 8 0 1 30092 Minifig Underwater Scooter 8 0 2 *30095 Bar 7 x 3 With Double Clips 2 7 1 30106 Castle Crystal Ball 3 7 0 30152 Minifig Tool Magnifying Glass 5 0 4 30182 Slope Brick 45 4 x 4 8 0 2 30208 Cylinder 4 x 4 Hemisphere Multifaceted 6 0 3 30236 Brick 1 x 2 with Handle 5 2 2 3039P01 Slope Brick 45 2 x 2 with Airplane Control Panel Pattern 5 0 4 32109 Electric Mindstorms RCX 8 x 12 Bottom Cover (needs work) 4 0 5 32140 Technic Liftarm 2 x 4 L Shape 5 1 3 3298P66 Slope Brick 33 3 x 2 with Pink Triangles Pattern 9 0 1 3613 Arm Piece with Towball Socket 7 0 2 3711 Technic Link Chain 6 0 3 3873 Technic Link Tread 4 4 1 3900 Minifig Tool Signal Holder (needs work) 5 2 2 425P01 Baseplate 32 x 32 Road 3 Lane with Road And Crosswalk Pattern 7 0 2 4497 Minifig Spear 4 0 5 4698 Technic Axle Nut 5 2 3 606P33 Baseplate 32 x 32 Airport Runway Straight Pattern 4 2 4 608P33 Baseplate 32 x 32 Airport Runway T-Junction Pattern (needs work) 5 0 4 6942 Scala Cone 5 x 5 4 0 5 70496 Technic Hook Large Metallic 8 0 1 70749 Minifig Knife 8 0 1 70750 Minifig Harpoon 6 0 3 71427 Electric 9V Mini-Motor 7 0 2 *80394 Container Box 2 x 2 x 2 Door with Slot and Fire Logo Pattern 6 1 2 *81038 Hose Reel 2 x 4 x 2 Holder with Fire Logo Pattern 7 0 2 *81155 Castle Wall 3 x 3 x 6 Corner with Blacktron I Logo Pattern 5 2 2 81174 Tile 2 x 2 Round with Archery Target Pattern 6 0 3 81890 Tile 1 x 2 with Computer Keyboard Pattern 4 1 4 X877 Electric Touch Sensor Brick 3 x 2 Top/Bottom Halves 4 1 4 X878 Electric Touch Sensor Brick 3 x 2 Sensor Peg 5 0 4 X879 Electric Touch Sensor Brick 3 x 2 (Complete Assembly Shortcut) 5 0 4 X883 Electric Mindstorms RCX Module 5 0 4 X884 Electric Mindstorms RCX (Complete Assembly Shortcut) 7 0 2 X890 Roadsign Clip-on 2 x 2 Octagonal 6 0 3 X891 Flag 7 x 3 with Rod 4 3 2 X996 Electric Brick 1 x 8 With 3 Lights Left (needs work) 2 4 3 X997 Minifig Soccer Ball (needs work) 4 3 2 X998 Electric Brick 1 x 8 With 3 Lights Right (needs work) Pieces that did not pass the vote: 2552 Baseplate 32 x 32 Raised with Ramp (needs work) 30106 Castle Crystal Ball 30152 Minifig Tool Magnifying Glass 3900 Minifig Tool Signal Holder (needs work) X997 Minifig Soccer Ball (needs work) Note: for those eagerly waiting for the soccer ball, a _good_ one is being worked on now. I have seen an early example, and it looks great. :-) _New Subparts added to the \S directory in this update: (long list!) 883-1.DAT ~Subpart Button for RCX Module 30208-1.DAT ~Subpart Cylinder 4 X 4 Hemisphere Multifaceted 32109-1.DAT ~Subpart Electric Mindstorms RCX Angled Bottom Stud For 32109 883-2.DAT ~Subpart Electric Ports for RCX Module LETAB.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Background LETBA.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Background LETBB.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Background LETCB.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Background LETRB.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Background LETXB.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Background NUMB0B.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Background NUMB1B.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Background NUMB2B.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Background NUMB3B.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Background NUMB4B.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Background NUMB5B.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Background NUMB7B.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Background LETAA.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Letter LETCA.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Letter LETRA.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Letter LETXA.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Letter NUMB0A.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Number NUMB1A.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Number NUMB2A.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Number NUMB3A.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Number NUMB4A.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Number NUMB5A.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Number NUMB7A.DAT ~Subpart for Mindstorms RCX Number 3626BS01.DAT ~Subpart Minifig Head - Faceless Subpart (hollow stud) 3626AS01.DAT ~Subpart Minifig Head - Faceless Subpart (solid stud) _New Primitives: No new primitives added. ------------------------------------------------------------------ _The following pieces passed, but were removed for serious quality-control reasons. In retrospect, I am somewhat at fault for this, as I should not have allowed these pieces into the vote without closer screening: 3004P01 Brick 1 x 2 with Computer Screen and Buttons Pattern 3298P66 Slope Brick 33 3 x 2 with Pink Triangles Pattern 425P01 Baseplate 32 x 32 Road 3 Lane with Road And Crosswalk Pattern 606P33 Baseplate 32 x 32 Airport Runway Straight Pattern 608P33 Baseplate 32 x 32 Airport Runway T-Junction Pattern (needs work) 3039P01 Slope Brick 45 2 x 2 with Airplane Control Panel Pattern 81890 Tile 1 x 2 with Computer Keyboard Pattern 81174 Tile 2 x 2 Round with Archery Target Pattern X996 Electric Brick 1 x 8 With 3 Lights Left (needs work) X998 Electric Brick 1 x 8 With 3 Lights Right (needs work) _Some patterned pieces had their numbers "corrected" prior to voting. The pieces now being released had those numbers changed back to their original xxxxPnn.dat format: 80394 back to 4346p01 Container Box 2 x 2 x 2 Door with Slot and Fire Logo Pattern 81038 back to 4209p01 Hose Reel 2 x 4 x 2 Holder with Fire Logo Pattern 81155 back to 2345p44 Castle Wall 3 x 3 x 6 Corner with Blacktron I Logo Pattern -"X" numbers kept as is, with the X dropped: 877 Electric Touch Sensor Brick 3 x 2 Top/Bottom Halves 878 Electric Touch Sensor Brick 3 x 2 Sensor Peg 879 Electric Touch Sensor Brick 3 x 2 (Complete Assembly Shortcut) 883 Electric Mindstorms RCX Module 884 Electric Mindstorms RCX (Complete Assembly Shortcut) 891 Flag 7 x 3 with Rod _Pieces put on "HOLD" pending problem resolution. The "problem" varies by piece: Question on orientation: 2524 Minifig Backpack Non-Opening 890 Roadsign Clip-on 2 x 2 Octagonal Problems of numbering/coloring: 30086 Boat 8 x 12 Inflatable Dinghy 2574 [category?] Pull-Back Motor 70496 Technic Hook Large Metallic 70749 Minifig Knife 70750 Minifig Harpoon 71427 Electric 9V Mini-Motor _Piece formerly on "HOLD", now added: 767 Train Track Sleeper Plate 2 x 8 without Cable Grooves _Piece added with minor pattern color change: 2440p69 Hinge 6 x 3 Radar/Blade/Spoiler/Panel w/ Yellow Radar Pattern -------------------------------------------------------------------- Summary of changes to existing parts: _Various tweaks and corrections: 3004p06 Pattern improvement to original piece. 3649 Improvement by author 2440p68 Description mod to match new 2440p69 4166 Description mod to match "on hold" part 767 above 6020 Description mod to sort better with new part 30095.dat 3626a | Minifig head modifications: 3626b | Corrected mis-sizing of heads, 3626bp01 >- Improved patterns, and added 3626bp02 | blank face support to the \S 82359 | directory. (Thanks, Chris Dee!) 3626b-4t ~moved to new \s directory blank face piece 3626bs01. 3193p01 ~moved to 3195p01 - this is a temp "~moved to" file subject " to deletion without further warning. Any uses of the part: " 3193p01.dat " "Door 1 x 5 x 4 Left with Red, White and Blue Stripes Pattern" " should be updated to 3195p01.dat as soon as possible. _Category changes: These are to prepare the way for the future inclusion of other types of plants within the same category. (The next vote has a plant that is not a tree) 2518 Category change from "Tree" to "Plants" 2536 Category change from "Tree" to "Plants" 2563 Category change from "Tree" to "Plants" 2566 Category change from "Tree" to "Plants" 3470 Category change from "Tree" to "Plants" _Description Mods to fix duplicate descriptions. Pieces received clarifications or corrections to descriptions. This fixes _most_ of the duplicate descriptions in the inventory: 6048.DAT Arm Piece with Pin and 2 Fingers 6217.DAT Arm Piece with Pin and 3 Fingers 4083.DAT Bar 1 x 4 x 2 with Studs 4730.DAT Brick 2 x 2 with Pin 6232.DAT Brick 2 x 2 with Pin and Axlehole 73312.DAT Door 1 x 4 x 5 with 4 Panes 3861.DAT Door 1 x 4 x 5 with 6 Panes 4587.DAT Horse Hitching with Hinge 4215P03.DAT Panel 1 x 4 x 3 with Red Stripe Pattern 6104.DAT Wing 8 x 8 with 3 x 4 Cutout 4475.DAT Wing 8 x 8 with 4 x 4 Cutout Some duplicates still exist. Use the new MKLIST.exe with the -c switch to see a listing of remaining duplicates. Suggestions to fix them welcome. _In addition, these three pieces were similarly modified to conform with the the changes above: 3612.DAT Arm Piece Straight with 2 and 3 Fingers 412.DAT Arm Piece Turned with 2 and 3 Fingers 30000 Brick 2 x 2 with Pins and Axlehole I _think_ this is a complete list of what has been done. :-/ -- Terry K --